patching...
Update: Follow New Milford Patch on Facebook »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Bergen Blue Laws Battle Headed to Court

Paramus seeks to enforce Blue Laws after Christie ordered them suspended.

 

It's been a week since Gov. Chris Christie issued the order to suspend Bergen County's Blue Laws so that residents most impacted by Hurricane Sandy could purchase necessary repair items. And while Paramus has the strictest Blue Laws on the books, County Executive Kathleen Donovan may take the borough to court this week to keep local officials from limiting what stores can be open.

Bergen County Executive Kathleen Donovan had asked the state last Saturday to suspend the county’s Blue Laws as the County struggled with numerous power outages. Christie gave the order on Sunday, Nov. 4 to allow for retail stores to open.

The Executive Order is meant to allow the sale of clothing and wearing apparel, building and lumber supply materials, furniture, home or business or office furnishings, household, business or office appliances.

But Paramus posted on its borough website that the remainder of the towns Blue Laws remain in effect. A letter was also issued to the Paramus Chamber of Commerce outlining what could and could not be sold on Sunday. Officials have stated they will enforce the laws and if need by fine any retail stores that attempt to sell books, jewelry, recreational and athletic equipment, or automobiles.

“You mean to tell me that Neiman Marcus and an $800 pair of Christian Louboutins are a necessity at this point? Come on,” Mayor Richard LaBarbiera told northjersey.com. “Or that the 100,000 square feet of jewelry stores need to be open in Paramus? It’s a wolf in sheep’s clothing. And I find it disingenuous that they think that this is necessary to address the needs of those people impacted by the storm.”

County officials stated they intend to head to court on Thursday seeking a ruling to prevent Paramus and any other towns from enforcing the Blue Laws.

Westfield Garden State Plaza posted on its Facebook page that it will be open on Sunday, 11am to 6pm. The  Bergen Town Center Paramus Park and Shops at Riverside will also be open on Sunday as well.

Related Topics: Blue Laws, Christie, bergen county, and paramus

Paula D. Weiner

7:11 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

I've lived in Bergen County my whole life. We need the Blue Laws to stay in affect to curb traffic on Sundays, especially from NYC. We have no sales tax on clothing and the traffic is horrible and does unnecessary damage to roads, etc. Not to mention car pollution. We need a day of rest.

Reply
Comment_arrow

News Man

10:01 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Buses should provided for all the "Gruntles and Disgruntles" to visit the court hearings when they are started.

Paramus is still trying to be the Tail wagging the NJ dog. Its shoppers.

Comment_arrow

Josh Hosseinof

1:34 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

NYC has no State or City sales tax on Clothing and Shoes under $110. So that's not a reason for anyone from NYC to come to NJ on Saturday or Sunday.

"unnecessary damage to roads" ? Aren't roads meant to be driven on?

Ralph

7:23 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Hey Wyckoff, how about changing the Blue Laws in your town allowing some sort of Retail labor since your law says for Moral reasons no Labor is allowed. It would be nice to be able to go to the Bank while I am driving right past it to go grocery shopping at Boulder Run. And by the way, arent the people in Stop and Shop doing labor? How about the labor in the restuarants? But you cant go to the bank or even get a haircut because labor is not allowed. Not saying that all of the things that are prohibited for sale is a bad thing but no personal services? Time to come into the real world.

Reply

BellairBerdan

7:25 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

"As you know, Bergen County has Blue Laws, which prohibit certain items from being sold on Sunday and certain stores are closed," Donovan wrote. "However, we are in the midst of an extraordinary crisis as the result of hurricane/tropical storm Sandy. Bergen County is suffering.

"Therefore, as Bergen County Executive, I am writing to you to request that you utilize the powers vested in you in your declaration of a State of Emergency to temporarily suspend the Blue Laws in Bergen County for Sunday, November 4, 2012 so that our people can purchase the items they otherwise would be restricted from purchasing so they can get on with their lives,"

Donovan has no shame using a crisis for her political purposes. The People have voted on this. Why is she wasting all of our money taking this to court? She'll use taxpayer money to benefit corporate interests. I stand with the People of Paramus on this.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Josh S

7:43 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Gov Cristie does not have the authority to be a dictator even if Ms Donovan samples her kid's pot.

Cece

8:25 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Keep the Blue Laws in place. If the Blue Laws are abolished (even for a short time), the quality of life for many Bergen County residents will decrease while the traffic will increase. With the holiday season just around the corner, I hope the executive order is withdrawn so that residents can have a day off from all the congestion. What we don't need is Sunday traffic on Routes 4 and 17.

Reply
Comment_arrow

jim

8:48 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Stay home on Sunday and you will not have to worry about the traffic. Lift the blue laws on Sunday.

Comment_arrow

janu

9:17 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

i think there is too much traffic on rt4 and 17 is because of blue law.. since everything is closed on sunday. everyone will shop on saturday..also i have been stuck in traffic on sunday as well on rt 4... because of blue law we are loosing so much revenue.. and to make up to that we have to pay higher taxes.. blue should be banned and let the town decide what stores can/can not be open on sunday..

Comment_arrow

JP

12:26 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Is your quality of life bad Monday trough Saturday??

Comment_arrow

EJ

9:07 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

I agree - I grew up here in the area (30+ years) and enjoy the respite that the Blue Laws gives us. It provides a unique benefit living in the NYC Metro area providing for an additional good quality of life (even if it's just for half of the weekend).

I don't believe people losing 1-day of shopping out of 7 under normal circumstances is life / death. For emergency situations like Sandy - sure keep stores open for critical supplies but once "normalcy" returns so does the law.

"Stay home on Sunday...", tell you what buddy - that doesn't contribute to quality of life. Being able to enjoy our towns without the usual traffic and on-rush of shoppers for just one-day a week day is worth fighting to keep. You can drive out to whatever it is you need if you need to shop that badly (really?).

People who have lived here for any significant period of time appreciate the additional quality of life while living within a stone's throw from New York City. Those who are new to the area really begin to appreciate it once they've been around long enough to experience it.

Ulises

9:05 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Lefting the Blue Laws now may lead to a permanent change to this law and a change to Sundays as we know it in Bergen County. When Christie came into office he wanted to do this from the start... Donovan has issued six lawsuits this year to try to get what she wants. This has cost tax payers over $230K and counting in legal expenses. I voted for her in hopes she curtail spending but it seems to me the power is getting to her head and the cost to get what she wants is costing us all dearly. She's proven to be a leader that is willing to go to court rather than working things out, even with her own party. I hope Paramus wins their fight against her and I don't think I'll vote for her next time around.

Reply

Keith Kaplan

11:01 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Get rid of the Blue Laws. The towns can opt to keep them if they want.

But the fact is that Paramus doesn't want to let Teaneck have stores open. Why should you dictate to MY town what stores can be open on Sunday?

Reply
Comment_arrow

zizi

2:34 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Keith: Teaneck will probably vote to close stores on Saturday...... go drive down cedar lane on Saturday....... I think... the real solution is to let everyone decide for them self - without any law dictating a day of no business.....

Seamus McKensie

12:35 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

If those residents backing the blue laws were SO interested in keeping their sacred Sunday day of rest then why have Sundays become Bergen County's Wide, VERY Wide World of Sports in EVERY town?

Don't you think that the issue of congestion on county roads goes both ways? Try navigating my street between the hours of 8:30am and 7:00pm on any Sunday. Lots of resting going on there! NOT!

A little hypocritical don't you think? So where is the peace really?

This has always been a dictatorial mandate from a group of people that are more concerned with their own agenda. Either give in to the wishes of the concerned constituents here and loosen up those blue law actions for the few who have always straddled that blue line anyway or shut EVERYTHING down on Sundays with NO exceptions and truly follow a path of one peaceful day per week here.

Reply

Dianne Glasner

7:02 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

The environment needs a rest. Keep Blue Laws....change them to another day if it makes you feel better, but give the area a break.

Reply

Josh Hosseinof

7:14 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

This sunday will be a good test of the often repeated claim that traffic would be unbearable without the blue laws. If shopping were allowed on Sundays in addition to Saturdays, then there wouldnt be such huge crowds on Saturdays on the roads.

Unfortunately the big malls and stores in Paramus will be ardent supporters of the county blue laws, because they know that while the rest of the county would love to abolish them, Paramus will still keep their own blue laws even if the rest of Bergen county opens up on Sundays.

Reply

Steve Sass

7:36 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Can someone explain the why the quality of life is worse for the other 20 counties in NJ without the blue laws? That is the lamest argument. The real problem is that the Paramus planning board screwed up and allowed the over development on Route 4 and 17. This is where the traffic. Now Paramus gets the benefit of the property taxes from the retail stores and the rest of Bergen county gets screwed. Why don't we allow blue laws to be voted for on a town by town basis? We are losing millions of dollars in tax revenue by forcing stores to close on Sundays. Just look at the malls in Rockland county on a Sunday. An even better idea is why don't we change the day we have blue laws from Sunday to Monday?

Reply

Paul Umrichin

7:56 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Good Luck Paramus. I may not agree completely, but I respect the choice.

Reply

jp1

7:59 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Keep Paramus blue laws. If retailers do not like them then they will go elsewhere.

Reply
Comment_arrow

rozette

8:20 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

what you sad makes no sense

rozette

8:08 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

I come from Suffolk County Long Island. I just started living here about 4 years ago. These stupid blue laws. The members of the Paramus Chamber of Commerce live in 19th Century. Hey guys it's 21st Centuty, get with it. What I do is when I can't shop for clothes I take my money and go to Palisades Mall. Huge place and let say, I tend to overspend because you can get everything conveniently in one place. All these other comments prior to this one are also people who old fashioned. Aren't you sitting at a computer and probably have a cell phone. Well get with it, get rid of the Blue Laws and be modern and not old fashioned.

Reply
Comment_arrow

zizi

2:00 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

@rozette: Welcome to Bergen county.... the home of ice-agers...... I never understand the logic of blue laws..... if you don't like to buy than stay home or do whatever you want... but please don't stop others to live their lives......

Michael

8:15 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

The blue laws should be banned county-wide and let the towns decide for themselves what ordinances to enact. Paramus is a staunch defender of its blue laws above and beyond those of the county; they have been overdeveloping for over 50 years but become holier-than-thou on Sunday. The hypocrisy is appalling. People outside my town are allowed to restrict commerce INSIDE my town so I have to travel out of county for clothes, hardware, etc. Let us choose our own day of rest.

Reply

Ridgewood Mom

8:20 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Shame on Kathleen Donovan for exploiting disaster for the goal of personal political aim. The people of Paramus have voted on this and we need to support their decision.

Reply

gary

9:34 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Lets not forget everytime the County Executive commences litigation the legal professionals picked by the County Executive make huge fees...

Reply

Brian

9:37 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

The Blue laws should be abolished as an economic stimulus for the area. We are talking about thousands of additional jobs and an increase in tax revenue. This is a no brainer between the storm and the economy. Lets try it thought 1/1 and see what happens.

The laws are from a time before 2 income households and people working until 8 or 9 at night. I literally have about 8 hours a week that I can go shop for shoes, clothes, etc. That certainly has an impact on my shopping habits.

Reply

Summer Chaser

10:42 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

In this economy........... i think perhaps it would be best to open the blue laws for the rest of the year......... passaic county stores are open..... and your neighbors could use the business too......

Reply
Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

12:37 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

How much better economically is Passaic County doing by not having Blue Laws?

Comment_arrow

Deleted because of harassment

1:36 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

If you want to do if for the economy, allow only those stores and businesses that have their corporate HQ in Bergen to open. That way, the money stays in Bergen. The retail jobs are at the bottom end of the economy, and they do very little to help it when the profits all go elsewhere. How about stores like Glen Rock Hardware, instead of Home Depot and Lowe's? Or eating at Fisher's Cafe instead of McDonald's? I doubt the traffic and congestion would be an issue if that were the case.

Joseph Joyce

10:53 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Paramus, whose four major shopping malls account for a significant proportion of the over $5 billion in annual retail sales generated in the borough, more than any other ZIP Code in the United States, has blue laws that are even more restrictive than those imposed in the rest of the County. Now, why are we talking about lifting them?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Brian

12:38 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Because they might be leaving a few $Billion on the table by closing on Sunday. $5 Billion is great. $7 Billion is better.

Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

12:43 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Because politicians have promised their corporate donors to get rid of them. They are using a disaster as a reason to accomplish this.

zizi

12:19 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Why not let towns decide for themselves....... state/county should get out of this business...... I think any laws limiting choices for people are problematic..... let the individuals/companies decide what they want to do..... open or not open...

Reply
Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

12:39 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

It's been voted on several times. The People chose to keep the laws.

Comment_arrow

zizi

2:03 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

I think individual towns should vote on this..... it should not be a county wide issue......

JP

12:30 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

It's all about jobs. Even opening one more day all over Bergen creates at least some jobs. I'd rather see people working and cash flowing to help this economy get stronger, faster.

Reply

barbara dube

1:25 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

KEEP THE BLUE LAWS. PARAMUS REAL ESTATE STILL IS THE MOST DOLLARS PER SQUARE FOOT IN THE NATION. IT IS THE ONLY DAY OF THE WEEK WE CAN GO UP AND DOWN ROADS WITHOUT CONGESTION.

Reply

Josh Hosseinof

1:27 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Last time it was voted on was1993 - almost 20 years ago. Times, and the population of the county have changed, and maybe now is the time to re-evaluate the laws. I'm more than happy to go to Paterson on Route 20, just next door to Fair lawn on Sundays where I can get anything I need from Home Depot, or computers / technology stuff at Micro Center, or any of the other stores along that area. It's a 10 minute ride from Teaneck or Paramus. I'm also happier because as Paterson is an enterprise zone I pay half the normal sales tax of the rest of NJ. I would be happier still to spend the money in my Bergen County if the stores would only be open on Sunday. The Blue laws only do one thing really well - cost the businesses and towns of Bergen county billions in lost revenue.

By the logic of complaining about the traffic jams we should have also banned the Giants and Jets football games on Sundays - those are in Bergen County also.

Reply
Comment_arrow

zizi

2:07 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

@Josh Hosseinof:.... the people who like blue laws also think this world is only 5000 years old..... and everything revolves around our earth...... the list goes on..... logic has little value to them....
Please don't tell them about the football games on Sunday..... once they will find out about football games on Sunday.. they might......

Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

4:02 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Josh, how exactly does that revenue benefit the town? In fact it would probably cost the town in extra services.

Those stores on Rt 20 opened because of the Blue Laws just across the river and because they were given an urban enterprise zone sales tax ( which Christie wants to do away with that too). Those stores never would have been there if not for those things.

But if I can figure out how I can do without something between the hours of 10PM -10AM because the stores are closed, I can figure out how do without it, or drive even closer to the stores on rt 20 on Sunday.

Put it to a vote again. If Christie can refuse to sign a marriage equality bill passed by the legislature because he wants it to go to a vote, why not honor the People's vote on this?

Comment_arrow

Leslie Wilson

5:04 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Blue Laws serve numerous purposes. I don't think the responders are acknowledging all of the reasons. I think convenience is the major issue to abolish them. Consumers in Bergen want to shop like shoppers in the the rest of the state. However, here are several points on why they probably should not be abolished. Bergen Co. decided to keep its laws to maintain a certain degree of prestige. There is more than one law. Hackensack, Teaneck and Paramus for example have modified Blue Laws. If shoppers stay within NJ to shop on Sunday, the taxable revenue stays within the state. The issue is not taxes. Most of the goods sold in Paramus' major malls don't produce taxes. There are no taxes on clothes in NJ. So the taxable income is coming from other goods, mostly items not sold at the Paramus malls. Yet, Bergen Co. was one of the first in NJ to launch an offensive against the big ticket stores like Home Depot forcing them to close by 10pm when they used to be open to midnight and denying Best Buy's late night sales. Is there massive outcry to get that reversed? Abolishing the laws is not going to create enough high paying retail jobs to make a difference. The retail industry is suffering and there are cutbacks in the workforce. The cost of traffic, like police and pollution, not just traffic, might be a factor. After a game or on Saturday nite you would see the massive traffic jams that last for miles & hours on 17, 4, 80 and NJT.
Let's get all of the facts & then decide!

FairLawn soccer mom

4:10 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

BA do you understand how economics works or just complain all the time? Commercial properties are valued by how much income they make. More income, more taxes paid.

How will it cost the town in extra services? Aren't the police already working?

Are you seriously comparing a local blue law vote with a statewide issue on something as inconsequential as gay marriage?

Did you hear the one about blacks don't support gay marriage...heck they don't support straight marriage - Chris Rock.

Reply
Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

4:21 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Wow, you're pretty messed up, aren't you?

FairLawn soccer mom

4:45 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Nah!! Life is AWESOME!

what services will it cost the town? I like going to Lowes on Sundays when I am not working

Reply
Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

5:38 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

So "washed ashore", did your name get banned for hate speech or did you make up this new one just for me?

Comment_arrow

BelareBurden

7:42 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

I didnt see any hate speech except from you! How are the failed policies of democrats doing today? Solve any problems or are there still poor and unemployed people out there? Woohoo Obama he's your man if he can't do it nobody can! Don't look now we just borrowed more money from china and still no one is better off.

Comment_arrow

Phil Jonas

12:18 pm on Friday, November 9, 2012

BellairBerdan You are full of Poppycock!

Joe Godin

7:31 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

I live in Teaneck and would like to shop on Sunday. We have now legalized marijuana in some sates and gay marriage in others. And I can't shop on Sunday precisely because....WHY? I regularly drive Monday-Friday along the 4 and 17 corridors and NEVER encounter any traffic except at rush hour when you would expect it. I also travel the back roads along 4 and 17 and also find traffic there to be manageable. It is hard to imagine that spreading the shopping week out over an additional day would increase traffic. Seems to me it would help achieve a more even distribution of traffic and LESSEN TRAFFIC. The most hectic traffic seems to come when schools let out and you are traveling behind a bus. Based on Paramus logic, should we then ban schools or school buses?

Reply

Concerned !

7:48 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012

Such a major debate but the answer is here over and over... Let this go town by town. If a town encounters additional traffic or anything else unwanted they will enable the blue laws. I would vote, campaign, and donate to any cause in Wyckoff that works towards removing these unjust laws. The premise is based on religious beliefs and I resent it, although I understand the more practical reasons (by town).

Reply
Comment_arrow

JP

9:45 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Even better... let it go business by business. Want to stay open, do so, don't, then don't. I didn't see a meltdown in Paramus last weekend because stores were open, did anyone?

Ricky

3:15 am on Friday, November 9, 2012

Blue laws, schmooo laws, it makes hardly a difference. There's a Lowes just off Rt. 80, a Home Depot both easily reachable by Bergen residents along the other side of the Passaic River. There's a Home Depot in Secaucus easily reachable by those in the southern part of Bergen, same story along Rt. 59 in Rockland for those in northern part of Bergen.

Reply

Macy

6:45 am on Friday, November 9, 2012

Does anyone remeber when you couldnt even go to a supermarket on Sunday??? I know I am dating myself but there was no internet, cable (Just plain old TV) cell phones and guess what families did family things like spend time together and visiting friends and family. Everyone managed, Sunday shopping has just become a way to get out of the house nothing more! Sure during an emergency stores like home depot, hardware stores and such should be open extra but do we really need a hugh mall open? REALLY?

Reply
Comment_arrow

NJ2020

9:37 am on Friday, November 9, 2012

yes. we do. Sunday is my only day off from work, so where do I shop? In New York State. Too bad NJ is missing out on my money. Blue laws are ridiculous. I do however think that towns (not the county) should have to right to choose whether they want them or not. I live in Ramsey where there is a lot of retail business. It would be nice to patronize those stores if they were open on Sunday...

Comment_arrow

BellairBerdan

2:04 pm on Friday, November 9, 2012

LW what makes you think you will have Sundays off for long if we continue to let big business chip away at what the People have voted?

james

9:41 am on Friday, November 9, 2012

Perhaps the merchants can give the Paramus sports teams a percentage of the revenue so we aren't accosted every Sat for donations. Guess the out of town traffic is very welcomed on those days.

Reply

Tee Smyth

9:43 am on Friday, November 9, 2012

I live in Teaneck, and agree with keeping the law as is. Good luck, Paramus. Keep up the good fight!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ricky

2:16 am on Saturday, November 10, 2012

Unless you rely solely on public transportation, these blue laws aren't a big hassle. Supermarkets are open and they carry batteries and many other items that can still be purchased. But again, there's a Lowes, Home Depot within a 15 minute drive of most of the county anyway. If you live in Elmwood Park or Fair Lawn, it's more like 5 minutes or less.

guee

4:34 am on Friday, November 30, 2012

called in his book a “healthy debate” http://www.coachfactoryoutletcc.us /Coach Outlet Onlineover troop levels in the country.But the president’s decision to tap

Mr. Petraeus to command the war in Afghanistan, http://www.guccibeltsoutletstores.net /Gucci Beltsand later picking him to lead the C.I.A., effectively ended lingering

concerns among Obama political advisers that the http://www.coachoutletonlinewo.com /Coach Outlet Storepopular general might challenge his commander in chief during

the election.Mr. Petraeus and his wife met http://www.coachfactorystoredo.com /Coach Factory Onlinewhen he was a cadet at West Point; she was the daughter of the

academy’s superintendent and a student at Dickinson http://www.coachfactoryoutletpo.com /Coach Factory Outlet OnlineCollegeinPennsylvania.condemnation on Wednesday.“

The Egyptian people, the Egyptian leadership, http://www.coachoutletonlinefc.org /Coach Outlet Onlinethe Egyptian government and all of Egypt is standing with all its

Reply

akemengde

11:44 pm on Friday, November 30, 2012

Buy more hot buns to http://www.coachoutletonlineybw.com Coach Outlet Online
far more slip by http://www.coachoutletstoreonlinesl.com Coach Outlet Store Online before. Almagro was in http://www.coachoutletaol.net Coach Outlet deep trouble at two but he dug himself out http://www.coachoutletwy.com Coach Outlet of trouble and passed, http://www.coachfactoryonlinefc.org Coach Factory Online the Spaniard against the http://www.coachfactoryoutletrb.com Coach Factory Outlet older man but Stepanek in the fourth http://www.coachfactoryoutlettx.com Coach Factory Outlet set and point, sparking scenes of http://www.coachfactoryoutletonlinewb.com Coach Factory Outlet wild celebration are very tough http://www.coachoutletstorexd.net Coach Outlet Store moments,"the defeat. http://www.coachoutletonlinescoach.net Coach Outlet Online "But we can't be moment. http://www.coachoutletonlinest.com Coach Outlet Store Online the same last year too!

Reply

Leave a comment